The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit cited OU Law Professor Sarah Burstein’s article, “The Patented Design” (83 Tenn. L. Rev. 161, 212 (2015)), in a design patent infringement decision.
In Curver Luxembourg, Sarl v. Home Expressions Inc., the Federal Circuit quoted Burstein’s article, which argues that particular designs — even those that are patented — should remain free to be adapted to different types of products.
In its opinion, the Federal Circuit affirmed the dismissal of a design patent lawsuit that household products maker Curver Luxembourg SARL brought against Home Expressions over storage baskets. Curver’s suit alleged that Home Expressions made and sold baskets that incorporated Curver’s claimed design pattern and infringed its 946 patent, titled “Pattern for a Chair,” which claims an “ornamental design for a pattern for a chair” with an overlapping “Y” design.
The Federal Circuit affirmed the opinion of the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey, which held that claim language specifying a particular article of manufacture (a chair) limits the scope of the design patent in cases where “the claim language supplies the only instance of an article of manufacture that appears nowhere in the figures.”
The court suggested that the limit is also good policy, citing Burstein’s work on the subject (see below).
The ruling was decided Sept. 12, 2019, and the full opinion may be read here.
More News & Media
News
OU Shines in preLaw's Rankings for Practical Training
NORMAN, OKLA. – The University of Oklahoma College of Law ranks 12 th in the nation in preparing students for the real world of law practice published in National Jurist’s spring 2024...
News
Federalist Society and ACS Gift Chess Set to OU Law
The University of Oklahoma College of Law was the recipient of a chess board donated by the school's chapters of the Federalist Society and the American Constitution Society. While the two groups...
News
OU Law to Honor Outstanding Alumni at Order of the Owl Hall of Fame Ceremony
NORMAN, OKLA . — The University of Oklahoma College of Law will honor five outstanding alumni at its annual Order of the Owl Hall of Fame ceremony Thursday, Feb. 22, at the Molly Shi Boren...